decisions
| |

They Weren’t in the Room: When People Don’t Understand the Decisions You Had to Make

After a particularly bad moment, again feeling the full weight of my story, and sensing the immense impact still wreaking havoc on many layers of life, a friend said, “You remind me of Captain Sully.”

I didn’t know what she meant so she explained further. I remembered the news story but I hadn’t seen the movie so I looked it up that evening.

Settling in with my heating pad on, I watched Sully, the movie with Tom Hanks about Captain Chesley “Sully” Sullenberger and the emergency landing of US Airways Flight 1549 on the Hudson River.

I knew the basic story. Birds hit the plane. Both engines were lost. Sully landed the plane on the Hudson.

What I wasn’t expecting was everything that came after.

Honestly, I couldn’t believe the parallel.

Not the plane crash part as much as the experience of going through something intense, making decisions in circumstances no one around you fully understands, and then facing the fallout afterward.

The questioning.

The assumptions.

They Weren’t in the Room

So many people looking at what happened from the outside and deciding what you could have or should have done differently. They couldn’t possibly know the feelings, the patterns, the moments.

In the face of their doubt, there’s the deep need to hold on to what you know happened even while someone else is presenting a completely different version of your reality.

I kept thinking: There are women who know exactly what this feels like.

When the Guidebook Doesn’t Have an Answer

At the beginning of the crisis in the movie, Sully and his first officer are doing what they’re trained to do. They’re looking at their options, communicating, running through procedures, and trying to solve an incredibly serious problem.

And then there comes a point when the normal options simply aren’t going to work.

That’s the part that stayed with me.

Sometimes you do all the things.

You pray. You get counseling. You read the books. You have the conversations. You try again. You wait. You forgive. You set a boundary. You change the boundary. You ask for help. You try the thing everyone keeps telling you should work.

And then there comes a moment when you realize:

This situation isn’t in the guidebook.

Maybe it’s a marriage that has become destructive. Maybe it’s your physical or mental health. Maybe it’s a situation with one of your children. Maybe it’s ministry, family, caregiving, burnout, divorce, grief, or a relationship that has become something you never thought it would become.

You didn’t train for this.

You didn’t want this.

But you’re here.

And decisions still have to be made.

And Then Everyone Gets to Have an Opinion

This is where the movie really got me.

In Sully, the movie portrays the investigation after the landing as increasingly adversarial. Simulations appear to show that Sully could have returned safely to an airport instead of landing in the Hudson. From the outside, with the benefit of simulations and hindsight, another choice appears possible.

And I thought, Oh my goodness. This.

Because isn’t that what can happen after we’ve lived through something incredibly difficult?

People investigate our choices without having lived our reality.

They start with assumptions that aren’t necessarily true.

They look at one moment without understanding the hundred moments that led up to it.

They tell us what they would have done.

They tell us there was another option.

And maybe there was another option on paper.

But they weren’t in the room.

They weren’t there for all the conversations.

They didn’t experience all the things that happened before the moment everyone now wants to analyze.

They didn’t carry the fear.

They didn’t know what you knew.

They didn’t know what you didn’t know.

Then you have to fight for evidence, defend and explain and tell the story again and again. You’re required to dig where the investigators won’t dig, insist on accountability, and fight incredibly hard for truth to see the light.

And they still interrogate, still ignore, still want deniability of responsibility.

These people, the ones who don’t know but think they know… they didn’t have to account for the humanity involved. They want an easy answer, easy solution, put the case to bed.

And that’s what struck me so deeply about the movie.

You Can’t Take the Humanity Out of the Story

There’s a pivotal moment in Sully when the flight simulations are being discussed. The simulations had the advantage of knowing exactly what was coming and what action to take. Sully challenges that because the actual people flying the plane didn’t know what was about to happen. They had to first recognize the emergency, understand what was happening, consider their options, and make a decision. The film eventually has a 35-second reaction and decision period added to the simulations.

That’s the human factor.

And something about that hit me hard.

You cannot take the humanity out of someone’s story and then fairly judge the decisions they made inside it.

We aren’t machines.

We don’t encounter devastating circumstances already knowing exactly what they mean.

Sometimes it takes us time to realize how unhealthy something has become. Often, it takes years. Especially in faith communities where forgiveness, don’t keep record, and love your enemy are highly held values.

The process of facing reality is a very hard and long journey.

Sometimes we need time to understand what is happening in our own bodies.

Sometimes we don’t recognize a pattern until we’ve lived through it repeatedly or someone points it out in black and white.

Sometimes we are simultaneously trying to protect children, preserve relationships, honor commitments, pay bills, keep working, maintain our faith, figure out what is true, and simply survive another week.

Then someone standing outside the situation says, “Why didn’t you just…?”

The look on their faces when they state their judgement or opinion or concern.

Just leave.

Just stay.

Just pray.

Just say no.

Just forgive.

Just set a boundary.

Just try harder.

Just stop letting it bother you.

But there was no “just” about it.

There was a human being in the cockpit.

And maybe that’s something you need to remember about yourself too.

The Crisis Was Hard. The Aftermath Might Be Harder.

I think I expected the river landing to be the emotional center of the movie.

It wasn’t for me.

It was the aftermath.

It was watching someone who had already been through something intense then have to revisit it repeatedly, explain decisions, listen to alternative scenarios, face questions about his judgment, and sit with the possibility that other people believed he had made the wrong choice.

I watched Sully, frantic after the crash, stand on the sidelines and hold his breath to see if everyone made it out alive. He turns slowly, watching the plane in the water, rescuers still searching for people, the medics on shore care for those already rescued, the reporters there with cameras, and the crowds surrounding it all look on in shock.

That felt familiar in an entirely different way. I felt that in the deepest parts of my soul.

Because sometimes surviving the actual thing is only the first part.

Then you live through the fallout.

Other people have questions.

Some people misunderstand.

Someone tells a different version of the story allowing a false narrative to seem true.

Relationships change.

People choose sides.

You replay things yourself.

You wonder what you missed.

You imagine alternative endings.

What if I had waited?

What if I had recognized it sooner?

What if I had tried one more time?

What if they’re right about me?

And here’s the tricky part: being questioned can make you question yourself.

Even when you knew what happened.

Hold the Line

This was written in big letters across my notes while I watched the movie:

STAND FIRM ON TRUTH.

And then:

Hold steady. Remain on the path. Let truth be seen in time.

I could hear Dr. Hawkins saying, “Hold the line.”

That’s what I kept noticing in the movie. Sully knew why he made the decision he made. When the simulations seemed to tell a different story, he didn’t suddenly abandon what he knew about the actual experience. He kept bringing the conversation back to the reality of what happened and to the human factors the simulations weren’t initially reflecting.

That doesn’t mean we decide we’re right and everyone else is wrong.

That’s not what I’m talking about.

Stay teachable.

Listen to wise people.

Ask hard questions.

Let God show you where you were wrong.

Own what is yours to own.

Apologize when you need to apologize.

Get counseling. Get help. Get perspective. Learn.

But being teachable doesn’t mean handing your story over to everyone who has an opinion about it.

There comes a point when you may have to say:

I know what happened.

I know what I experienced.

I know what I tried.

I know why I made the decision I made.

And I can remain open to truth without continually putting myself on trial.

I wrote two other words while watching:

SURE + SECURE.

Not sure because everyone agrees with you.

Not secure because everything worked out beautifully.

Not sure because you have no regrets.

Not secure because you never wake up at 2 a.m. and wonder if you should have done something differently.

I mean something deeper.

A slow, tested knowing.

I did the best I could with the reality I was actually living.

Maybe there are things you would do differently now. Of course there are. We all get information later that we didn’t have then.

Maybe there are pieces that belong to you that you need to own.

Own them.

But don’t start owning pieces that aren’t yours simply because someone else needs you to carry them.

That’s where security matters.

When There Is Fallout

Maybe you are living in that season right now.

Something happened.

Something changed.

You made a decision.

And now you’re dealing with the fallout.

People don’t understand.

Somebody is telling the story differently.

Children, friends, church communities, family — all reeling.

You’re facing people who weren’t in the room but have decided that they know what happened in the room.

You might be tired of defending yourself.

And honestly, maybe you don’t need to keep defending yourself to everyone.

Maybe the work now is quieter.

Go back to what you know.

Journal it.

Slow the moments down.

Listen to the different parts of yourself. The scared part. The angry part. The part that desperately wants everyone to understand. The part wondering whether you should go back and fix everything. Let those parts speak without letting every one of them take over.

Separate facts from fear.

Ask God for wisdom.

Ask Him to show you what belongs to you and give you the courage to own it.

Then ask Him to help you release what doesn’t.

They Weren’t in the Room

I think there’s something important about accepting that some people will never completely understand.

They weren’t in the room.

And you may spend an enormous amount of energy trying to bring people into a room they weren’t in, explaining details they didn’t see and defending decisions they didn’t have to make.

Maybe healing includes letting go of the need for everyone to understand.

Let the people who are safe and wise ask questions.

Let truth correct you.

Let God work on the places in you that still need healing.

But you don’t have to live forever inside someone else’s interrogation of your life.

At some point, you get to stand up from that table.

You get to walk forward.

Not because there was no fallout.

Not because everybody finally agreed.

Not because nothing hurt.

But because you know more clearly now what is yours and what isn’t.

You know what you lived.

You know why you made the decisions you made.

You know where you need grace, where you need growth, and where you need to hold the line.

And maybe you still don’t know exactly where the road goes from here.

That’s okay.

You’ve navigated roads you never thought you’d have to travel before.

You’ve gone through something you never planned or trained for.

You don’t need the entire route today.

You just need enough truth, courage, and grace to take the next healthy step.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *